[Bialenia] "Sformułowanie nowego zjawiska - Reakcja McMelkora"
: 29 lip 2026, 08:51
Greetings to the Kingdom of Dreamland, from the Anglophone community. Forgive me for using English, my Polish isn't good enough for me to hold a conversation within the language.
I came across a paper a while back from the University of Bialenia discussing the semi-recent situation in Elderland (and what the author dubbed as the "McMelkorian Reaction"), describing what one may dub a "reactionary" response to newcomers seeking to revitalize what seems to be a long-dead micronation against Simon McMelkor, who considered Elderland to be his own intellectual property. (I do want to note for the reader's sake that a similar situation has occurred in Anglophony in the past year or so, though unlike the Elderland situation, it began with a supposed coup and came to involve DMCA takedowns and a rival emperor being coronated; for more information on that conflict, read here.)
With regards to the paper, I fail to see why it shouldn't be labeled as I have described it — a form of reactionism against newcomers, if that's the proper terminology — instead of slapping someone's name on it and calling it a day. I could be mistaken in citing this, but Erik von Hohenburg (writing in a thesis he wrote at the university here at Dreamland some years back) described a form of "micronational solipsism", which I quote here now:
I came across a paper a while back from the University of Bialenia discussing the semi-recent situation in Elderland (and what the author dubbed as the "McMelkorian Reaction"), describing what one may dub a "reactionary" response to newcomers seeking to revitalize what seems to be a long-dead micronation against Simon McMelkor, who considered Elderland to be his own intellectual property. (I do want to note for the reader's sake that a similar situation has occurred in Anglophony in the past year or so, though unlike the Elderland situation, it began with a supposed coup and came to involve DMCA takedowns and a rival emperor being coronated; for more information on that conflict, read here.)
With regards to the paper, I fail to see why it shouldn't be labeled as I have described it — a form of reactionism against newcomers, if that's the proper terminology — instead of slapping someone's name on it and calling it a day. I could be mistaken in citing this, but Erik von Hohenburg (writing in a thesis he wrote at the university here at Dreamland some years back) described a form of "micronational solipsism", which I quote here now:
Would this description of a "McMelkorian Reaction", or at least its association with McMelkor, thus fit under the concept of solipsism as von Hohenburg described it? To associate someone's name with micronational reactionism (or irredentism, or whatever the term is) would seem IMO to do so.Solipsyzm w uproszczonej formie i w kontekście mikronacyjnym można byłoby zdefiniować
jako naturalne w naszej sytuacji dążenie jednostki do wymuszenia na całej społeczności
mikronautów uznania swojej subiektywnej wizji w sferach działalności mikronacji, których nie
da się w sposób oczywisty udowodnić...
[In a simplified form and within the context of micronationalism, solipsism could be defined as an individual's natural drive—given our circumstances—to compel the entire community of micronationalists to accept their subjective vision regarding aspects of micronational activity that cannot be objectively proven...]